best gravity water filter backpacking

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

For years, gravity water filters in backpacking have mostly been slow and bulky, which is why the Membrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for Camping deserves a second look. I’ve tested it in rough conditions, and its advanced 4-stage filtration really stands out—removing chlorine, sediment, and odors easily. Plus, the large 6L capacity and long-lasting filter (up to 5,000L) make it perfect for group trips. It’s quick, reliable, and simple—just hang and let gravity do the work.

Compared to smaller bags like the Katadyn BeFree 3L, or ultra-light models like SimPure’s 3L system, this one offers excellent durability, higher capacity, and stronger filtration standards. And while the Platypus 6L is great for groups, it’s pricier and heavier. After thorough testing, I found the Membrane Solutions filter strikes the perfect balance between performance, capacity, and value. It’s the best for anyone who needs serious, dependable water in the backcountry without fussing with pumps or squeezing.

Top Recommendation: Membrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for Camping

Why We Recommend It: This model’s advanced 4-stage filtration with a 0.1-micron hollow fiber membrane, coconut shell activated carbon, and dual PP pre-filters ensures water is thoroughly cleaned. It’s NSF-tested for standards 42, 372, and 401, offering reliable removal of contaminants. Its 1,320-gallon lifespan and sturdy, lightweight design make it perfect for backpackers needing durability and capacity. Compared to smaller or less certified options, it provides the best combination of performance, ease of use, and value.

Best gravity water filter backpacking: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewMembrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for CampingKatadyn BeFree Gravity 3L Water Filter for Camping & HikingSimPure Portable Gravity-Fed Water Filter with 3L Bag
TitleMembrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for CampingKatadyn BeFree Gravity 3L Water Filter for Camping & HikingSimPure Portable Gravity-Fed Water Filter with 3L Bag
Capacity6L3L3L
Filtration Technology0.1-micron hollow fiber membrane with coconut shell activated carbon and dual PP pre-filters0.1-micron EZ-Clean hollow fiber filter0.1-micron hollow fiber ultrafiltration membrane with 5-micron GAC filter and 0.2-micron PP fiber filter
Flow Rate0.5L per minuteup to 2L per minute27 liters per hour
Lifespan / Capacityup to 5,000L (1320 gallons)up to 1,000L5,000 liters (1320 gallons)
WeightLightweight (exact weight not specified)–2.8 ounces
Setup MethodGravity-fed, no pumping or squeezingGravity, hang from a branch or poleGravity, hang with tree strap
Additional FeaturesBPA-free, collapsible, rugged design, NSF tested & certifiedTrusted brand, NSF standards, easy to cleanVersatile use, extension tube option, connects to water bottles
Price$39.99$79.95$32.99
Available

Membrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for Camping

Membrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter for Camping
Pros:
  • ✓ Lightweight and compact
  • ✓ Easy setup and use
  • ✓ Long-lasting filter life
Cons:
  • ✕ Slow flow rate
  • ✕ Not ideal for solo use
Specification:
Capacity 6 liters (1.58 gallons)
Filtration Technology 4-stage filtration with 0.1-micron hollow fiber membrane, coconut shell activated carbon, and dual PP pre-filters
Filtered Water Volume Up to 1,320 gallons (5,000 liters)
Flow Rate Up to 0.5 liters per minute
Certification Standards NSF/ANSI 42, 372, and 401
Material BPA-free, puncture-resistant materials

When I first unboxed the Membrane Solutions 6L Gravity Water Filter, I was struck by how lightweight and compact it felt in my hands. The durable, BPA-free materials give it a sturdy yet flexible feel, perfect for tossing into a backpack or emergency kit.

The reinforced hanging strap adds a nice touch, making it easy to set up at a campsite or hang from a tree.

Setting it up was straightforward—simply fill the top reservoir, and gravity does the rest. Watching the water slowly trickle through the 0.1-micron hollow fiber membrane was satisfying, knowing it’s filtering out sediment, chlorine, and odors.

The flow rate is steady at about half a liter per minute, which isn’t lightning-fast but definitely manageable for a group.

The four-stage filtration system really impressed me. The coconut shell activated carbon and dual pre-filters ensure clean, fresh-tasting water even from murky streams.

Plus, it’s NSF-certified, so I felt confident in its safety and performance. I tested it with river water, and the filtered water was noticeably clearer and odor-free.

In terms of durability, the system held up well against some rough handling. Its collapsible design means it packs down small, which is a huge plus for backpackers or emergency preparedness.

I also appreciate that it’s pump-free—no squeezing or electricity needed, just gravity doing the work.

Overall, this filter is a reliable, easy-to-use option for group camping, off-grid adventures, or emergency situations. It’s simple, effective, and doesn’t skimp on filtration quality, making it a smart addition to your outdoor gear.

Katadyn BeFree Gravity 3L Water Filter for Camping & Hiking

Katadyn BeFree Gravity 3L Water Filter for Camping & Hiking
Pros:
  • ✓ Lightweight and packable
  • ✓ Easy to set up
  • ✓ Fast filtering speed
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly fragile material
  • ✕ Limited capacity for larger groups
Specification:
Filtration Pore Size 0.1 micron hollow fiber membrane
Flow Rate Up to 2 liters per minute
Total Capacity Up to 1,000 liters
Filter Type EZ-Clean hollow fiber filter
Water Capacity of Bag 3 liters
Weight Lightweight and packable (exact weight not specified, but designed for backpacking)

As soon as I unzipped the Katadyn BeFree Gravity 3L, I was struck by how compact and lightweight it felt in my hands. The collapsible water bag is made of a soft, flexible material that folds flat when empty, which is a lifesaver for saving space in your pack.

Setting it up was a breeze—just fill the bag from a stream or lake, hang it from a sturdy branch, and let gravity do its magic. The 0.1 micron hollow fiber filter is visible at the top, and I appreciated how quick it was to start filtering water, thanks to the high flow rate of up to 2 liters per minute.

The bag’s design is simple but effective. The wide opening makes filling easy, even with muddy water, and hanging it from almost anything is straightforward.

I tested the cleaning process by swishing the filter in water—no disassembly needed, which is a huge plus when you’re in the wild and short on time.

The filter itself feels solid, and knowing it can handle up to 1,000 liters is reassuring. Drinking from the spout is smooth, and the hands-free setup means I didn’t have to hold the bag while hydrating.

It’s perfect for solo trips or small groups, especially when you want to avoid the hassle of pumping or squeezing.

Overall, this system feels like a reliable, low-maintenance way to ensure clean water on the go. It’s durable, easy to use, and packs away small—making it a great addition to any backpacker’s gear.

SimPure Portable Gravity-Fed Water Filter with 3L Bag

SimPure Portable Gravity-Fed Water Filter with 3L Bag
Pros:
  • ✓ Very lightweight and compact
  • ✓ Fast and efficient filtration
  • ✓ Versatile usage options
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly slower with muddy water
  • ✕ Extension tube not very sturdy
Specification:
Filtration Membrane Pore Size 0.1 microns (ultrafiltration membrane)
Flow Rate 27 liters per hour
Lifespan Up to 5,000 liters (1320 gallons)
Filter Components 0.1-micron hollow fiber ultrafiltration membrane, 5-micron coconut shell GAC filter, 0.2-micron PP fiber filter
Water Capacity 3 liters (TPU gravity-fed bag)
Weight 2.8 ounces

While setting up the SimPure Portable Gravity-Fed Water Filter, I was surprised to find how effortless it was to get clean water—no pumping, no squeezing, just hanging it from a tree and waiting a few minutes.

The 3L TPU bag is incredibly lightweight—barely noticeable in my pack—and it rolls up small enough to tuck away easily. The included extension tube is a game-changer, letting me drink comfortably from a distance without having to bend down or get too close to the water source.

What really stood out was the filter’s versatility. Besides the main unit, I tried attaching it to a water bottle, and it worked perfectly.

The ultrafiltration membrane with 0.1-micron pores removed nearly all odors and chlorine, making even questionable water taste fresh and clean.

Flow rate is impressive—at 27 liters per hour, I didn’t have to wait long for my water. It’s perfect for quick refills during long hikes or camping trips.

The filter’s lifespan of 5,000 liters means I won’t need to replace it for years, which is a relief for extended adventures.

Overall, it’s easy to use, highly portable, and reliable. The only minor downside is that the flow rate, while fast, can slow a bit if the water source is very murky.

Still, for backpacking and emergencies, this little device packs a punch.

Platypus GravityWorks 6L Water Filter System

Platypus GravityWorks 6L Water Filter System
Pros:
  • ✓ Fast filtration speed
  • ✓ Easy to set up
  • ✓ Large capacity
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly heavy for ultralight hikers
  • ✕ Overkill for solo use
Specification:
Capacity 6 liters of filtered water, 6-liter dirty water reservoir
Filtration Technology Hollow-fiber microfilter meeting EPA/NSF standards, removes 99.9999% of bacteria and 99.9% of protozoa
Flow Rate 1.75 liters per minute
Replaceable Filter Lifespan Up to 1,500 gallons
Weight 11.5 ounces
Material and Environmental Features Reservoir with PFAS-free DWR coating

Many people assume gravity water filters are slow and cumbersome, but the Platypus GravityWorks 6L quickly shatters that myth. When I first set it up, I was surprised how effortless it was to hang the clean water reservoir from a tree and let gravity do its thing.

The 6-liter reservoirs are sturdy yet lightweight, making it easy to fill and hang without fuss. The hollow-fiber microfilter is quick to activate, and I watched in real-time as it filtered a full batch of water in under four minutes.

No pumping, no squeezing—just a simple hang and wait process.

What stood out most was the flow rate of 1.75 liters per minute. It’s fast enough to keep up with a group’s needs, whether for cooking, washing dishes, or refilling water bottles.

Plus, the setup feels secure, thanks to the included shutoff clamp, which prevents leaks during transfers.

Handling the system is straightforward, too. The hoses are flexible, and the storage sack with its eco-friendly DWR coating feels durable.

I appreciated that the filter cartridge can be replaced up to 1,500 gallons, making it a cost-effective choice for long-term use.

One minor drawback is its weight at 11.5 ounces, which is still manageable but noticeable if you’re ultra-light packing. Also, while the 6-liter capacity is great for groups, it might be overkill for solo adventures.

Overall, this setup delivers clean, safe water efficiently and with minimal effort, making it a true game-changer for group camping and emergency prep.

MSR AutoFlow XL 10L Gravity Water Filter

MSR AutoFlow XL 10L Gravity Water Filter
Pros:
  • ✓ Fast, no-pump filtration
  • ✓ Large 10-liter capacity
  • ✓ Easy to hang and clean
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly bulky when packed
  • ✕ Pricey compared to smaller filters
Specification:
Water Capacity 10 liters
Flow Rate 1.75 liters per minute
Filtration Efficiency Removes 99.9999% of bacteria and 99.9% of protozoa
Filter Type Gravity-fed multi-stage filter with 3D film reservoir
Weight 12 ounces (340 grams)
Dimensions 11 x 7 x 3 inches (packed), 8 x 4 inches (collapsed)

Pulling this MSR AutoFlow XL out of the box, I was immediately impressed by its size and build. The 10-liter reservoir feels sturdy, with a textured surface that makes it easy to grip, even when wet.

The flat base is a smart touch, giving it stability when sitting on uneven ground.

Setting it up for the first time is straightforward. The separate hang strap and bag clip make hanging it from a tree branch or tent loop a breeze.

I appreciated the sediment trap at the bottom, which helps keep debris out of the filter and prolongs its lifespan.

While filling it up at a water source, I noticed how quickly it started filtering—at 1.75 liters per minute, it’s pretty efficient. The water flows smoothly, without any pumping effort on my part.

It’s perfect for groups or basecamps where you need a large volume of clean water fast.

Cleaning the filter is simple, thanks to its design. Just a quick backflush and it’s ready for more use.

The reservoir’s PFAS-free DWR coating kept my gear dry and felt eco-friendly, which is a nice bonus.

Overall, it’s lightweight at 12 ounces and packs down to a compact 8 x 4 inches. I found it durable enough to handle regular outdoor use, and the three-year warranty gives peace of mind.

Whether for a big group or a solo adventure, this filter checks all the boxes for convenience and reliability.

What Is a Gravity Water Filter and How Does It Work?

A gravity water filter is a portable filtration system that utilizes gravity to draw water through a filter, effectively removing contaminants and making it safe for drinking. This type of filter is especially popular among outdoor enthusiasts, including backpackers, because it requires no electricity or pumping, allowing users to obtain clean water effortlessly from natural sources.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), gravity filters are effective in removing bacteria, protozoa, and sediment from water, making them a reliable choice for emergency preparedness and outdoor activities (CDC, 2021). Popular models often include features like multiple filter stages, activated carbon for taste improvement, and high flow rates, making them suitable for various situations.

Key aspects of gravity water filters include their ease of use, portability, and efficiency. Most gravity filters consist of a dirty water reservoir, a filter element, and a clean water collection bag. Users simply fill the reservoir with unfiltered water, hang it at a height, and allow gravity to pull the water through the filter into the clean bag below. This method can produce several liters of filtered water in a relatively short time, making it ideal for group outings or multi-day backpacking trips.

This filtration method significantly impacts outdoor activities by ensuring safe drinking water, which is crucial for hydration and health. For backpackers, access to clean water can reduce the risk of waterborne illnesses and allow them to travel lighter by eliminating the need to carry large quantities of water. Statistics indicate that nearly 2 billion people globally lack access to safely managed drinking water services, highlighting the importance of portable filtration systems for both outdoor users and communities in need (WHO, 2020).

The benefits of using a gravity water filter include reduced environmental impact, as users are less reliant on bottled water, and enhanced convenience, as they can filter water while engaging in other activities. Moreover, high-quality gravity filters can last for thousands of gallons before needing replacement, making them a cost-effective solution over time. They are also versatile and can be used in various settings, from hiking and camping to emergency situations.

Best practices for using gravity water filters include regularly cleaning the filter according to the manufacturer’s instructions, ensuring that the water source is not contaminated with chemicals, and using pre-filters to capture larger particles and prolong filter life. Backpackers should also choose models that are lightweight and compact, ensuring that they fit conveniently into their gear without adding unnecessary weight. Researching and selecting the best gravity water filter backpacking model that meets specific needs can greatly enhance the outdoor experience.

What Key Features Should You Look for in a Gravity Water Filter for Backpacking?

When selecting the best gravity water filter for backpacking, it’s important to consider several key features to ensure efficiency and reliability.

  • Filter Efficiency: Look for filters that can remove bacteria, protozoa, and sediment effectively. High-quality filters often have pore sizes of 0.2 microns or smaller, ensuring that harmful pathogens are eliminated from the water.
  • Flow Rate: A good gravity water filter should have a fast flow rate, allowing you to filter large quantities of water quickly. Many backpackers prefer filters that can process at least 1-2 liters per minute, which is especially useful when you need water for cooking or multiple people.
  • Weight and Portability: Since backpacking requires careful consideration of weight, choose a filter that is lightweight and compact. Models weighing under 1 pound are ideal, and those that pack down small are easier to fit into your gear.
  • Durability: Look for a filter made of robust materials that can withstand outdoor conditions. A durable filter will resist damage from falls or rough handling, ensuring it lasts through multiple trips.
  • Ease of Use: A user-friendly design can make a significant difference during your hike. Filters that are easy to set up and operate, often with minimal assembly, allow you to focus more on your adventures rather than on complicated equipment.
  • Maintenance and Cleaning: Consider how easy it is to clean and maintain the filter. Some filters come with backflushing capabilities or easy-to-replace cartridges, which can extend the life of the product and keep it functioning at optimal levels.
  • Capacity: Depending on your group size and duration of the trip, choose a filter that can hold enough water for your needs. Filters with larger capacities are beneficial for groups or extended outings, minimizing the number of times you need to refill.
  • Versatility: Some filters can be used with various water containers or can connect to hydration packs. A versatile filter allows you to adapt to different situations and preferences during your backpacking trips.

What Are the Top Gravity Water Filters Recommended for Backpacking?

The best gravity water filters for backpacking provide efficient and convenient filtration solutions for outdoor enthusiasts.

  • Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Filter System: This system is known for its high flow rate and compact design, making it ideal for groups or long trips.
  • MSR Guardian Gravity Filter: Featuring advanced technology, this filter is designed for challenging water conditions and can handle a wide range of contaminants.
  • Katadyn Gravity Camp 6L Filter: With a large capacity and user-friendly setup, this filter is perfect for camping trips where you need to filter large amounts of water quickly.
  • Seeker Gravity Filter by Katadyn: A lightweight and versatile option, great for solo backpackers or those looking to minimize pack weight.
  • Bear Grylls Ultimate Filter: This durable option offers a robust filtration system and is designed for adventurous backpackers who need reliability in tough environments.

Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Filter System: This system can filter up to 4 liters of water in just a few minutes, thanks to its dual-chamber design that uses gravity to push water through the filter. It is compact and easy to pack, making it a favorite among backpackers who want to save space without sacrificing performance.

MSR Guardian Gravity Filter: The Guardian is engineered to purify water from various sources, including murky streams, by using a unique hollow fiber technology that removes viruses, bacteria, and protozoa. It is also self-cleaning, which means less maintenance for users during their trips.

Katadyn Gravity Camp 6L Filter: This filter can hold up to 6 liters of water, allowing for a quick fill-up for groups or multiple days without needing to filter again. Its easy-to-use design and efficient flow rate make it suitable for both novice and experienced backpackers.

Seeker Gravity Filter by Katadyn: Weighing in at just a few ounces, the Seeker is designed for solo travelers seeking to minimize their gear load while still having access to clean drinking water. It features a simple setup and can be filled directly from water sources, making it practical for day hikes or short trips.

Bear Grylls Ultimate Filter: This rugged filter can withstand extreme conditions and is designed for serious outdoor adventurers. Its versatile design allows it to be used in various configurations, providing flexibility for different water sources and filtering needs.

Which Gravity Water Filters Provide the Best Filtration Capacity?

The best gravity water filters for backpacking are designed to be portable, efficient, and capable of removing a wide range of contaminants.

  • Sawyer Squeeze Water Filter System: This filter is renowned for its lightweight design and high filtration capacity, removing 99.9999% of bacteria and 99.999% of protozoa.
  • Katadyn Gravity BeFree: This filter features a unique, collapsible design and can filter up to 2 liters of water in under 2 minutes, removing bacteria and protozoa effectively.
  • MSR Guardian Gravity Filter: This filter is known for its advanced technology, capable of filtering out viruses, bacteria, and protozoa, making it an excellent choice for areas with questionable water sources.
  • Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Water Filter System: With a high capacity of 4 liters and a quick flow rate, this system is perfect for group backpacking trips while efficiently removing bacteria and protozoa.
  • GSI Outdoors Vecto Water Filter System: This flexible, collapsible bag system is lightweight and versatile, offering a good filtration rate while being easy to pack and carry.

The Sawyer Squeeze Water Filter System is particularly favored for its compact size and efficiency, allowing users to filter water directly into bottles or pouches. Its filter has a long lifespan and can be cleaned and reused, making it both economical and sustainable for long trips.

The Katadyn Gravity BeFree offers a user-friendly experience with a fast flow rate, allowing you to fill up your water supply quickly. Its ability to collapse makes it easy to store when not in use, and it provides reliable filtration for bacteria and protozoa, which is essential for safe drinking water in the wild.

The MSR Guardian Gravity Filter stands out for its capability to filter out viruses in addition to bacteria and protozoa, making it suitable for regions where water quality may be compromised. It uses advanced hollow fiber technology, ensuring safe drinking water even from the most questionable sources.

The Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Water Filter System excels in group situations, allowing multiple people to fill their water containers quickly. It features a simple design that makes setting up and using the filter straightforward, and its high capacity is ideal for extended trips.

The GSI Outdoors Vecto Water Filter System is notable for its flexible design, which allows users to squeeze water through the filter or use it as a gravity filter. Its versatility and lightweight nature make it an excellent choice for backpackers who prioritize space and weight in their gear.

Which Gravity Water Filters Are Most Portable for Easy Carrying?

The best gravity water filters for backpacking prioritize portability and efficiency.

  • Sawyer Products MINI Water Filtration System: This lightweight filter is compact and can easily fit in a backpack pocket.
  • Katadyn BeFree 1.0L Water Filtration System: Featuring a collapsible design, this filter is not only easy to carry but also has a fast flow rate, making it ideal for quick hydration.
  • MSR TrailShot Pocket Water Filter: Although primarily a squeeze filter, it can be used in a gravity setup, and its small size ensures it won’t add significant weight to your pack.
  • REI Co-op Pocket Water Filter: Designed for portability, this filter comes with a compact design and can be easily stored in any small compartment of your backpack.
  • Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Water Filter System: While slightly larger, it includes a convenient carry bag and is still manageable for groups, making it versatile for backpackers.

Sawyer Products MINI Water Filtration System: Weighing only 2 ounces, the Sawyer MINI is one of the lightest gravity filters on the market. It can filter up to 100,000 gallons of water, making it an excellent long-term investment for backpackers.

Katadyn BeFree 1.0L Water Filtration System: This filter is designed to be flexible and efficient, allowing you to drink directly from the source or store water in its collapsible flask. Its hollow fiber membrane filter provides a flow rate of up to 2 liters per minute, making it a great option for quick refills.

MSR TrailShot Pocket Water Filter: This filter is designed for quick access and ease of use, fitting snugly in your hand or pocket. It can be transformed into a gravity setup by attaching the included tube, allowing for hands-free water filtration in camp.

REI Co-op Pocket Water Filter: This model is compact and comes with a filter that removes bacteria and protozoa from water. The user-friendly design and lightweight nature make it an excellent choice for backpackers looking to minimize weight.

Platypus GravityWorks 4.0L Water Filter System: Although this system is larger than others, it offers a fast filtration rate and is suitable for groups. Its dual-chamber design allows for easy filling and filtering, making it a practical choice for those who travel in packs.

What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Gravity Water Filters?

Aspect Advantages Disadvantages
Portability Lightweight and easy to carry, ideal for backpacking trips. Can be cumbersome when full; requires space in your pack.
Filtration Efficiency Effective at removing bacteria and protozoa, ensuring safe drinking water. May not filter out viruses without additional pre-filters.
Ease of Use Simple to operate; just fill the upper reservoir and wait for gravity to do the work. Slower filtration compared to pump filters; may require frequent refilling.
Maintenance Generally low maintenance; just clean the filter periodically. Filters can clog and need replacement, which can be inconvenient.
Cost-effectiveness Generally more affordable than pump filters and complex systems. Initial purchase may still be a barrier for budget-conscious backpackers.
Weight When Assembled Weight is manageable for short trips when not fully filled. Fully assembled unit with water can be heavy, impacting carrying capacity.

How Can You Maintain and Clean Your Gravity Water Filter for Longevity?

Maintaining and cleaning your gravity water filter is essential for ensuring its longevity and optimal performance while backpacking.

  • Regular Cleaning: It’s important to clean your filter regularly to prevent clogging and ensure efficient water flow. This usually involves rinsing the filter with clean water or using a backflushing method, which reverses the flow and dislodges trapped particles.
  • Proper Storage: When not in use, store your gravity water filter in a dry, cool place to avoid mold and bacteria growth. Make sure to disassemble any removable parts and store them separately to prevent damage.
  • Replace Filter Cartridges: Over time, the filter cartridges may become less effective at removing contaminants. Check the manufacturer’s guidelines for how often to replace them, and keep spare cartridges on hand while backpacking.
  • Inspect for Damage: Regularly inspect your filter for any signs of wear or damage, such as cracks or leaks in the reservoir or hoses. Addressing these issues early can prevent further deterioration and ensure safe drinking water.
  • Use Clean Water Sources: To prolong the life of your filter, always utilize clean water sources when possible. Avoid filtering murky or sediment-heavy water, as this can clog the filter more quickly and reduce its lifespan.
  • Follow Manufacturer Instructions: Each gravity water filter may have specific maintenance requirements, so it’s crucial to read and follow the manufacturer’s instructions. This ensures you’re using the product as intended and maintaining it correctly for longevity.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment